comcast blocking smtp25
John Chambers
jc at trillian.mit.edu
Fri Jul 15 18:35:02 EDT 2005
Don Levey <lug at the-leveys.us> wrote:
> Snooping on email? What makes you think that you're not still
> vulnerable? They still own the hardware, up to the point it connects
> to your house. They could, if they want, capture all the packets
> that enter/leave your home. Sending encrypted email might help - with
> both situations.
It's perhaps worthwhile to note that there's another reason that ISPs
have blocked ports 25 and 80: Ownership of the files. There have been
numerous discussions of this on music-related lists for example.
The prime case was a couple of years ago, when msn.com was caught
extracting things (mostly images) from customers' web sites and using
them in ads. When this got publicised and customers got outraged,
msn's reply was to point to the fine print in their contract, which
said that any files stored on their servers became the property of
msn.
It really hit the fan when this got publicised, and msn publicly
backed down. However, people have pointed out that their rewording of
the contract mostly had the result of obfuscating the legal
situation. Lawyers have said that they are likely still claiming
copyright on any files on their servers, but now it'll take a court
case to settle the issue due to the legal language used.
The effect of this is that there's a high likelyhood that if you
store anything, even "in transit", on an ISP's servers, you may very
well have assigned the copyright to them. This is an obvious threat
to musicians who are putting their music online. It also potentially
affects anyone whose livelyhood depends somehow on "publishing"
anything. Writers, journalists, researchers, and so on. There's a
good chance that if something you make becomes commercially
successful, your ISP can come along and sue you for violating their
copyright on the fragments that you stored on their servers.
They probably couldn't make a copyright claim on the contents of
single IP packets. But if any of your files are financially valuable,
you may want to think twice before allowing them to reside, even
temporarily, on your ISP's servers.
More information about the Discuss
mailing list